A Place for All of Us

Last week, I saw Steven Spielberg’s remake of West Side Story with Rachel Zegler as Maria and Ansel Elgort as Tony.  Rita Moreno, who played Anita in the 1961 version, played Valentina, the wife of Doc, who was the original owner of Valentina’s drugstore. 

This fabulous musical—which whips emotions into a frenzy with enthusiastic dancing and impassioned characters—was relevant back in 1961, a time when racism was high in the United States.  For goodness sakes, the Civil Rights Act wasn’t even passed until 1964, three years after this original musical. 

The Civil Rights Act outlawed discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, national origin, and later sexual orientation and gender identity.  This act sought to establish equality for voter registrations, prohibited racial segregation in schools and public places, and outlawed discrimination in employment.

West Side Story, first written in 1957 by Jerome Robbins was inspired by Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet.  Remember, Romeo and Juliet came from two different feuding families in Verona.  Robbins wanted his lovers to come from two different religions in America—Maria was to be a Jewish girl and Tony was supposed to be from a Catholic family.

But when Laurents and Leonard Bernstein started collaborating on the musical, they drew inspiration from the Chicano riots in Los Angeles.  By the time the musical was complete, the setting had been moved to New York and the opposing gangs were represented by the Puerto Ricans and poor white communities of the city’s West Side.

The 2021 version is spectacular, and as relevant as ever.  The two opposing factions could be any community in America: men verses women, Whites verses Blacks, heterosexuals verses gays, Christians verses Muslims.  Even though the 1964 Civil Rights Act was supposed to establish equality for every person in the United States, it didn’t.   

People aren’t equal here, and diversity still seems to threaten our various cultures.  Women have not achieved equal pay for equal work, and, even when they work, they experience inequality at home when they are expected to bear most of the responsibility for raising children and doing housework. 

African American men are viewed as dangerous and irresponsible and too often become the targets of police officers or white vigilantes. Furthermore, African Americans are dehumanized for their dark skin and course and curly hair.   

Muslims are labeled as terrorists just because they share the same religion with terrorists on the other side of the world. 

When gay couples want to have children, they are criticized and ostracized.  Transgender individuals are the victims of rape and ridicule. 

American society is still a white supremist society, and most white people don’t understand how pervasive this damaging attitude is to the non-white cultures of our country.  So when two people from different cultures fall in love, their ability to sustain that love is fraught with hatred from their respective communities. 

In Steven Spielberg’s version of West Side Story, Rita Moreno sings the song that begins with “There’s a place for us, some where a place for us.”  She sings about a place with peace, quiet, and open air.  She sings about a time for togetherness, time for recreation, time for learning and caring. 

The poor and discriminated in the United States don’t live in places of peace and quiet.  They live in places filled with pollution, noise, and stress.  They don’t enjoy togetherness when families break down due to financial hardship and lack of opportunity.  They don’t have time to play.  Stress takes up their opportunities to learn, and they don’t feel like anyone cares. 

I cried in the dark theater as Rita Moreno sang this song. 

When will women ever feel as equal as men in American society?  When will their assertiveness and leadership be valued as much?  When will African Americans overcome the cavernous damages that slavery imposed upon them?  When will religions ever learn to respect every individual no matter their gender, sexual orientation, or creed? 

Rita Moreno sang about how, if we hold hands, we can be “halfway there.”  Holding hands requires empathy for one another.  We’re not practicing empathy too well these days.

Let’s really get into each other shoes.  Choose the people who are the most unlike you, and ask yourself, “How would I like to be treated?”  Maybe then, we can start holding hands and finding a place for all of us.